Aetna Group Health

Star Ratings

Value★★★☆☆3.0
Renewals★★½☆☆2.5
Claim Administration★★★★4.0
Customer Service★★★½3.5
Overall★★★☆☆3.0

Who Aetna Is Best For

💊

Pharmacy-Heavy Workforces

Groups with high specialty-drug or maintenance-medication utilization benefit from Caremark integration — copays and network steerage align perfectly.

🏪

Retail, Hospitality & Service Industries

MinuteClinic access at CVS locations across the Front Range provides convenient primary care for hourly employees without a PCP relationship.

🧘‍♀️

Wellness-Forward Cultures

Attain by Aetna, Vitality, and integrated mental health (through CVS HealthHUB) support employers building a wellness-first benefits story.

🏢

Mid-Market Self-Funded Groups

Aetna’s Signature Administrators PPO and ASO reporting tools compete well against UHC and Cigna for 100–500 life groups.

Why Colorado Employers Choose Aetna

  • CVS Caremark PBM integration: Real savings on pharmacy spend, especially for specialty medications.
  • MinuteClinic & HealthHUB access: Convenient, low-cost care at CVS retail locations — often $0 copay for members.
  • Aetna Funding Advantage: Level-funded product for 5–100 life groups with potential surplus refunds.
  • Strong behavioral health platform: Aetna’s mental-health network is among the largest in Colorado.
  • Caveat: Aetna’s Colorado hospital network lags UHC and Anthem — always confirm local access before switching.

Renewal Increase History

Aetna’s 15-year average renewal is approximately 8.4%. Historically the carrier tends to buy market share with aggressive first-year pricing and then correct through meaningful renewals in year two. Broker leverage is essential to keep Aetna renewals competitive.

Aetna Annual Rate Increases (2011–2025)

2011

9.1%

2012

8.4%

2013

7.8%

2014

8.1%

2015

7.7%

2016

7.9%

2017

8.3%

2018

8.0%

2019

7.5%

2020

6.0%

2021

7.7%

2022

9.5%

2023

10.2%

2024

9.9%

2025

9.3%

← Back to all carriers comparison

Get an Aetna Quote

For pharmacy-heavy or wellness-focused groups, Aetna can be a hidden gem. We’ll quote it alongside the other 7 major Colorado carriers.

Request a Quote →